Certificate of Appropriateness Applications

4633 Arden Avenue is located on the east side of Arden Avenue, just north of Country Club Road. The existing home on the subject property was built in 1938 and is classified as an American colonial cottage style in the Country Club National Register nomination documents. The current application is for an amendment to the approved COA, specifically for changes to the previously approved garage elevations. The proposed changes are: 

•  Eliminate stairway bump out and window on South/Rear elevation
•  Eliminate window on East/Left elevation.
•  Add windows to garage door on North/Front elevation.
•  Add service door to West/Right elevation
• Change exterior cladding on garage from brick to siding (match house) on North and South elevations (new garage will be all lap siding to match house).

This request is on the March 12, HPC meeting agenda. 

2021 Approved Elevations: 

Proposed Elevations:Original 2021 COA

Applicant Submittal

1-5-24 The project no longer includes the addition to the front facade/front entry. The windows will be replaced with windows of the same size. See email on page 2 of updated applicant submittal (linked below). 

4509 Wooddale Avenue is located on the east side of Wooddale Avenue south of Sunnyside Road and north of Bridge Street. The existing home on the lot is a two story home built in 1928. The applicant is requesting a certificate of appropriateness for the demolition and construction of a new detached garage and changes to the street facing façade of the existing home. The applicant is proposing a new three car detached garage. Changes to the street facing façade include a change in window size on some windows and a new covered entry. 

UPDATED APPLICANT SUBMITTAL

Applicant Submittal

4633 Arden Avenue is located on the east side of Arden Avenue, just north of Country Club Road. The existing home on the subject property was built in 1938 and is classified as an American colonial cottage style in the Country Club National Register nomination documents. The current application is for an amendment to the approved COA, specifically for the reconstructed chimney and for changes to the front entry. The city's building official ordered the chimney be removed for safety reasons and the request to the HPC is for the design of the replacement chimney. The applicant is requesting a larger front door and changes to the front porch to accommodate a zero entry doorway. The additional door height will be extended lower (the height of the house is not changing).

This request is on the October 10, HPC meeting agenda. 

Applicant Submittal

Applicant Submittal 2

Original 2021 COA

4904 Arden Avenue is located on the west side of Arden Avenue, north of  50th Street West and south of Country Club Road. The applicant is requesting a COA for additions to the first and second floor associated with a remodel project. The existing home on the subject property was built in 1945, outside the period of significance in the district. 

This request is on the May 9, HPC meeting agenda. 

Applicant Submittal

On April 18, 2023 the City Council denied the appeal request and upheld the decision of the HPC. 

The applicant has requested the public hearing be continued to April so they are able to attend the meeting in person. The public hearing will be continued and will take place at the City Council meeting on April 4, 2023. The Council will then take action on the appeal at the April 18th City Council meeting. 

The Heritage Preservation Commission denied this COA request at the January 9, 2023 HPC meeting. The applicant appealed the decision of the HPC to the City Council. This item will be heard at the March 7th City Council meeting. The Council will take action on the appeal at the March 21st City Council meeting. 

Link to January 9, 2023 HPC Packet

Link to January 9, 2023 Meeting Audio

The applicant is requesting the approval of an amendment to the existing COA at 4630 Drexel Avenue. The applicant is asking the HPC to approve the elevation without the stone fireplace surround detail on the rebuilt chimney. 

Applicant Submittal

2022 COA amendment Submittal 

Previous Amendments/Original COA BTE Links:

https://www.bettertogetheredina.org/coa/forum_topics/4630-drexel-avenue-request-to-change-roof-material-and-reconstruction-of-the-chimney

https://www.bettertogetheredina.org/coa/forum_topics/4630-drexel-avenue-request-to

https://www.bettertogetheredina.org/coa/forum_topics/h-20-6-4630-drexel-avenue

March HPC Submittal

This item was continued to the March HPC meeting. The applicant agreed to come back to the HPC with updated elevations that reflected comments from the HPC. 

A certificate of appropriateness was denied by the HPC for a new detached garage at 4909 Bruce Avenue at the December 13, 2022 meeting. The applicant took feedback from the HPC and redesigned two options for the proposed new roof on a new detached garage . 

Applicant Submittal

This item was continued to the January 9th HPC meeting.

Staff was notified that the as-built elevations of the project at 4510 Sunnyside Road do not match the plans previously approved with the original certificate of appropriateness. The property owner was notified, and are requesting the HPC approve the elevations as built. The change from the original COA elevations is to the second floor dormer. The second floor dormer/gable was shown much larger on the plans previously approved with the COA. 

Applicant Submittal-Letter to the HPC from homeowners, approved COA elevations, building permit elevations, and current photo

 

This item was continued to the January 9th HPC meeting.

Staff was notified that the as-built elevations of the project at 4604 Browndale do not match the plans previously approved with the original certificate of appropriateness. The property owners were notified, and are requesting the HPC approve the elevations as built. The change from the original COA elevation is to some of the tile detailing and the metal window box details on the street facing facade. 

Applicant Submittal-Letter to the HPC from homeowners, approved COA elevations, building permit elevations, and current photo

This COA was denied by the HPC at the December 13, 2022 meeting. 

4909 Bruce Avenue is located on the east side of Bruce Avenue, north of 50th Street West and south of Country Club Road. The existing home on the lot is a two-story home that was built in 1927. The applicant is requesting a certificate of appropriateness for the demolition and construction of a new detached garage. 

Applicant Submittal

The Heritage Preservation Commission denied this COA request at their August 11th HPC meeting. The applicant has appealed the decision of the HPC to the City Council. This item will be heard at the October 6th City Council meeting. The Council will take action on the item at the October 18th City Council meeting.

This item was continued from July to the August 11th meeting of the Heritage Preservation Commission.  

4633 Arden Avenue is located on the east side of Arden Avenue, just north of Country Club Road. The existing home on the subject property was built in 1938 and is identified as an example of English Cottage Style but classified as an American Colonial Cottage in the Country Club National Register Nomination documents. The application includes updated building materials due to the exterior brick being removed from the house, and the addition of a new second story window. 

Applicant Submittal

Applicant Submittal-August Meeting